Flash in the Pan 

Good milk vs. bad milk

A mutant protein has invaded the world's dairy supply, including, most likely, the jug of milk in your fridge. The protein, called A1 beta-casein, is well known in the scientific community. While most dairy companies, trade groups and government agencies consider it harmless, a growing body of research implicates A1 beta-casein in diabetes, heart disease, autism and schizophrenia.

The original mutation is believed to have occurred 8,000 years ago, causing cow zero and its offspring to produce milk in which the amino acid histidine occupies the 67th position of the beta-casein protein found in milk solids. The amino acid proline occupies that position in the non-mutant, original form of the A2 protein. Today, the average vessel of milk contains milk from many cows, with a mixture of both A1 and A2 beta-casein.

click to enlarge food_flash1-1.jpg

Keith Woodford, a professor of farm management and agribusiness at Lincoln University in New Zealand, is spreading the word about what he believes to be the dangers of milk containing A1 beta-casein. His book Devil in the Milk builds on more than 100 peer-reviewed studies to present a compelling case that A1 milk poses substantial health risks.

The book is a technical read, and conspiracy theorists will find it gripping, as Woodford details the extent to which corporations and government bodies with entrenched interests in maintaining A1 milk's reputation have disputed, ignored and silenced evidence suggesting there might be a problem.

If Woodford is right, those fighting to sweep this research under the rug are endangering the health of millions, if not billions, and for little in the way of return. He says it would be a simple matter to completely remove A1 beta-casein from the word's milk supply.

A New Zealand company, A2 Corporation, has patented means of testing cattle for the A1 mutation. The company assists dairies in switching their herds to A2 production, which takes about two generations, or 10 years. A2 Corporation also certifies dairies that produce pure A2 milk, and helps market it. While Woodford makes it clear neither he nor his family have any financial interest in A2 Corporation, it's also clear he hopes the company succeeds.

Countries with the highest levels of A1 in their milk also have the greatest incidence of Type 1 diabetes and heart disease, Woodford explains. This observation inspired a study on rodents, in which one group of rats was fed A1 beta-casein and the other was fed A2. None of the A2 group developed diabetes, while half the A1 group did. Other animal studies implicate A1 in heart disease.

The evidence linking A1 milk to autism and schizophrenia follows similar lines: correlations in population studies and support from animal studies, but scarce research on human subjects.

Direct research on humans, Woodford explains, is fraught with ethical and practical difficulties: "The subjects of the trial would need to be identified as babies and then put on either A1 or A2 formula milk once breastfeeding ceased. The trials would probably need to go on for many years, and the children prevented from eating any 'ordinary' dairy products. The parents of each child would need to give permission and be actively involved, but could not be permitted to know whether their beautiful and initially healthy baby was getting the A1 or A2 formula."

A1 defenders have latched onto the lack of direct proof of a link between A1 milk and any diseases. There's "not sufficient evidence for the claims being made by the marketers of A2 milk," I was told, via e-mail, by the National Dairy Council's Stacey Stevens. "Reviews of the science to date confirm there's no reason to think A2 milk might have health benefits beyond those of regular milk."

This statement seems to dodge the fact that the issue I'd asked her about isn't the supposed health benefits of A2 milk, but the possible health risks of A1 milk. Stevens responded to my initial query promptly, but I received no response when I asked her to clarify the Dairy Council's position by agreeing to the statement, "There is no reason to think that A1 milk might have health risks."

Stevens' response is typical from the dairy industry. Woodford thinks it's a result of fear that the public will get scared off of all milk.

"We're comfortable that all milk, A1 milk, A2 milk, is really good for you and you should keep drinking it," said Carole Inkster of the New Zealand Food Safety Authority in a New Zealand television report on A2 milk. Fred Brenmuhl, of New Zealand Federated Farmers responded to the potential dangers of A1 milk by saying, "Stopping the consumption of milk products is probably more dangerous than anything else."

If you wish to avoid A1 beta-casein, you have a few options:

—Milk from goats and sheep doesn't contain A1 beta-casein.

—Dairy products made from milk fat, like butter, don't contain A1 beta-casein, even if the milk they were made from did. The jury is still out on the A1 content of cheese and yogurt.

Beyond the one-time expense and inconvenience of switching their herds, Woodford says there is little for the dairy industry to fear in the possibility that A2 milk is safer, and he regrets the industry continues to view the issue as more of a risk than opportunity. While frustrated, he isn't completely surprised, even at resistance from within the scientific community. He cites many examples of slow acceptance of new medical ideas, including Robin Warren's 1979 discovery that stomach ulcers are caused by bacteria. Warren received the Nobel Prize in 2005, Woodford writes, but in 2000 "the work was still being described as 'controversial.'"

Ask Ari: Filling the social calendar

This week I'm giving airtime to two western Montana food events.

The growing contingent of Bhutanese students in Missoula is planning it's third annual "Chilies and Happiness" party at the PEAS Farm, scheduled for the "auspicious date of October 3," according to organizer Tshewang Wangchuk. It begins at 4 p.m. In addition to games, music, prayer-flag making, kids activities and other goings-on in celebration of Bhutanese culture in Missoula, the event has gained a deserving reputation for its massive, delicious and free Bhutanese feed for all who attend. Among other items on the menu, the meal is guaranteed to include ema-datse, the fiery signature dish of Bhutan, made with Bhutanese chilies grown at the PEAS Farm specifically for the occasion. And there's an unconfirmed rumor that a certain columnist will be in town and at the event.

For more information, visit http://bhutaninmontana.blogspot.com. Elsewhere in the state, Pearl Miles wrote to announce that the Big Sky Country Harvest Festival also turns three this year.

The family-friendly event—Sept. 18–20, just outside Hot Springs—"encourages the exchange of goods, services and information for greater local and regional self-reliance. Farmers, gardeners, craftspeople, musicians, artists and others from Montana and adjacent states and provinces will showcase their mostly hand grown, handmade products for sale and barter. The event promises good food and many fun activities, including a play area for kids, arts/crafts, bring your musical instruments for music circles and informative speakers and workshops."

Sound good. For more information, e-mail bigskycountryharvestfest@yahoo.com.

Send your food and garden queries to flash@flashinthepan.net

  • Email
  • Print

More by Ari LeVaux

© 2015 Missoula News/Independent Publishing | Powered by Foundation